By Brenda Pittman, CIH, CSP, Certified Industrial Hygienist

Click here to view draft changes and comments.
Some core provisions have remained unchanged. Specifically, the Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) of 50 µg/m3 and Action Level of 25 µg/m3 remain, as in the 2024 Rule. MSHA’s emphasis on engineering and administrative controls to control dust, rather than reliance on respirators, also remains unchanged.
The proposed revisions include changes to exposure sampling, miner rotation, respirator use, medical surveillance, and how sampling results will be evaluated for compliance.
Exposure Sampling Would Change Significantly
- Initial sampling to comply with the rule would change. Operators would no longer be required to collect two samples, on separate days, below the Action Level to comply with the rule initially. Only one sample day is now needed. If changes as defined by the operator, re-sampling should occur.
- Repeated sampling every three months when exposures are above the Action Level or PEL is no longer required. MSHA’s proposal allows the operator to “conduct sampling as frequently as necessary.”
- Periodic (six-month) evaluation would be eliminated. MSHA proposes eliminating the paperwork obligation of conducting and documenting an evaluation of the process and equipment to determine miners’ potential exposure.
- Operators would still be required to report exposures above the PEL to MSHA. MSHA has opted to continue requiring operators to notify the district manager (or a designated representative) if an operator sample comes back exceeding the PEL. However, MSHA is now proposing that it will not cite an operator based on the operator’s test sample results.
Enforcement of the PEL Clarified
The proposal clarifies that citations will be based on MSHA-collected samples above the PEL, with a uniform error factor adjustment of 21 percent. So, a citation would not occur unless the worker exposure was 121% of the PEL.
Medical Surveillance Obligations Would Be Reduced
The proposal would also change the 2024 rule’s medical surveillance obligations. First, all mine operators, not just metal and nonmetal mines, would be required to provide certain medical examinations.
For metal and nonmetal operators, medical examinations that previously were mandatory for all miners new to the industry would instead become voluntary. Mandatory medical examinations would be triggered only for miners whose exposure exceeds the PEL, as determined by an MSHA sample.
Sampling Results Would Drive Different Follow-up Obligations
The proposal would also change how operators should respond to the results of their own sampling.
- Below the action level: no follow-up sampling would be required.
- At or above the action level but below the PEL: respiratory protection would have to be made available before the miner’s next shift and maintained until sampling demonstrates exposure below the action level.
- At or above the PEL: additional corrective-action requirements would apply, and the overexposure must be reported to the MSHA District Manager.
- Following corrective actions: once sampling demonstrates exposure is at or below the PEL, the operator would have to contact the MSHA District Manager.
Respiratory Protection Programs Would Follow OSHA’s Standard
While the 2024 rule required respiratory protection programs to conform to certain ASTM provisions, the proposal would generally require compliance with OSHA’s respiratory-protection standard at 29 C.F.R. § 1910.134, subject to narrow exceptions involving oxygen-deficient atmospheres and recordkeeping. Mine operators would still follow MSHA’s applicable recordkeeping requirements.
For companies that also operate OSHA-regulated facilities, alignment with § 1910.134 may make respiratory-protection programs more familiar and easier to administer across operations.